The film's rousing prologue introduces us to four performers who are brought together to become an internationally famous magic act known as The Four Horsemen. We have a fast talking street trickster Danny (Jesse Eisenberg), the mentalist Merritt (Woody Harrelson), pickpocket Jack (Dave Franco), and the lovely escape artist Henley (Isla Fisher). Fast forward a year later, the Horsemen have a millionaire benefactor Arthur Tressler (Michael Caine) who funds their lavish hi-tech Vegas stage act and are on the radar of a former magician Thaddeus Bradley (Morgan Freeman), who makes millions from online videos by breaking the illusionists' bro code and debunking the stage acts of other performers.
The Horsemen conclude their shows with an elaborate literal bank robbery where worthy audience members see their checking accounts swell by tens of thousands of dollars. So the stage is set and it brings them under the eye of the FBI led by Agent Dylan Rhodes (Mark Ruffalo) and Parisian INTERPOL Agent Alma Dray (Melanie Laurent). The foursome have more high stakes heists up their sleeves in their next two performances in New Orleans and Queens, New York, which leads to their cat and mouse pursuit from interantional authorities.
In the true high bar set by The Prestige, the characters stay steps ahead of both the audience and each other. Upon repeated viewing, you actually catch clues brilliantly laid out before you and had not noticed before. Now You See Me attempts no such bold depth, and relies on little subtlety instead using broader strokes to reveal its secrets in flat out flashbacks.
To keep us happy, the curtain is pulled back several times and we do get to see how some tricks are executed. That's fine and its also crucial to the plot, but when written off under the cloak of magical powers, we are assaulted with characters performing numerous physically impossible feats that defy physics. Also in revealing how some of their escapist illusions are actually pulled off, the insane necessary resources readily available to them makes you take pause for plausibility.
A true highlight is an inspired sequence in an apartment where Franco's Jack has a drag out test of wits opportunity to escape an FBI raid. He literally dazzles and battles the agents with practical magic. Its an all too brief glimpse of the film's real world potential when most of the showy illusions utilized are so outlandish they shatter any hope for sustained suspension of disbelief. But watching quick thinking, ingenuity and magician's tools take on the feds in hand to hand combat is where the film hits its target.
Director Louis Leterrier (The Incredible Hulk, Clash of the Titans) breaks into several sudden well staged action packed chase sequences (and he's damn good at it), but they come as fast as they go and tend to come off as gratuitous ploys to amp up the action for what feels should be a thinker's paced film.
The film is blessed with a superb cast, each one bringing enough to the table in this ensemble cast. But as a far as our four lead magicians are concerned, beyond some witter banter there is little connect or perceived camaraderie between them beyond their broad projected on-stage relationship. They have been a team for over a year, and there is scant chemistry and at the end of the day, it seems they all still distrust each other. Even when one of them is taken out of action, the remaining three show no remorse in the loss. Whether it should be presented on screen as justified misdirection to the audience or not, it doesn't make the team appear to be the close knit group you should be rooting for. Ruffalo has a good time with his role here, and it shows on screen. Academy Award winners Freeman and Caine provide nothing less than the solid backbone you would expect from them.
The story itself is straightforward but multi-layered and moves along with a brisk pace that you have to keep up with. Leterrier keeps the camera moving and circling about constantly and allows you little time to over think at any time. There are very few moments when things slow down and it by no means lacks visual flare or flashy special effects. But the sometimes lavish CGI takes away from grounding the magic in a real world setting, which the film finds a hard time defining. By the time the credits roll and the plot points are all out of the sorting hat, you definitely feel its take on the magical line has been blurred completely.
Despite being a lively well cast heist film, there is not much of a magic show in terms of sheer wonderment. Now You See Me is a harmless lighthearted romp that supplies ample action, twists and turns, and will keep you ultimately guessing on where its all leading to. I am probably most guilty of the fatal error of having my hopes up too high based on the film's intriguing first trailer below, but that is the effective magic of early marketing at work.
Now You See Me opens in theaters on May 31st.
REVIEW RATING: ★★½☆☆☆
Director: Louis Letterier
Starring: Jesse Eisenberg, Mark Ruffalo, Woody Harrelson, Melanie Laurent, Isla Fisher, Dave Franco, Michael Caine, Morgan Freeman
Screenwriters: Ed Solomon, Boaz Yakin, Edward Ricourt
Studio: Summit Entertainment
Rated: PG-13
Running Time: 116 minutes
